Ongoing CRIS projects: mood disorders
Prevalence of Treatment Resistant Depression (TRD) in Child and Adolescent Mental Health Services (CAMHS) for 11-18 year olds
Depression in adolescence is relatively common and, unfortunately, in certain cases difficult to treat with either medication, such as antidepressants, or psychological treatments such as counselling and CBT. We are unclear how often treatment fails in the first instance and resistance occurs. It is important to know this, so that we can understand how big the problem is and, importantly, look at ways of improving our treatments for depression in this age group.
Conducting a study of people with depression who appear not to be getting better on a single medication
In clinical trials of treatments for people with mental illness, a group of patients are given a treatment (called the “intervention arm” of the trial) and compared to another different group who are given an inactive or placebo (the “control arm”). At the end of the trial the patients in both arms are compared to see if the treatment made a difference to their symptoms or overall quality of life. Importantly, the comparison allows side effects and adverse events to be monitored thus establishing the safety of the treatment. Participating in clinical trials can be burdensome for patients and usually there are no immediate treatment benefits for volunteering. Results from controlled clinical trials are often criticized because the patients enrolled are not sufficiently representative of the patients who might receive the treatment in the future. Finally, existing trials can be inefficient because often, for every patient in the intervention arm, many more patients are required in the control arm to make statistically valid comparisons.
Consequently, researchers have sought ways to make trials more efficient and at the same time make results more applicable to “real world” clinical practice. One approach is to conduct a traditional clinical trial, but at the same time, enroll a group of patients who won’t be given the experimental treatment. These patients will continue their existing treatment in the usual way they would in the NHS and these participants form what is known as an external control arm (ECA). At the end of the trial researchers can then compare people in the treatment arm with those in the ECA to examine the frequency of side-effects, changes in symptoms and safety data for patients who had their usual treatment. For example, if researchers think a new medication might cause people to faint, they can see how many people fainted in the intervention arm and compare this statistically to those in the ECA. Additionally, many illnesses fluctuate over time so patients in the external control arm can add valuable information about the natural time course of symptoms and adverse events when looking for clinically meaningful differences when compared to participants in the treatment arm.
Oxford Health NHS Foundation Trust (OHFT) and the University of Oxford have partnered with Akrivia Health (an Oxford-based health technology company) to deliver an external control arm for a study sponsored by Janssen, a pharmaceutical company. Janssen are conducting a study of people with depression who appear not to be getting better on a single medication. We will approach patients who are treated by OHFT to see if they would consider being a participant in this external control arm. Participants will continue their care and treatment with their NHS team and participation in the study will not modify their current or any future treatment plans with their team. Participants will be asked to attend a series of regular interviews with the study team, over approximately one year and to have blood tests – as they would in a traditional clinical trial and these are in addition to their usual care or treatment plan.
In addition, each participant will be asked if their anonymised medical records can be examined at regular intervals using technology developed by Akrivia Health in collaboration with the team at OHFT and the University of Oxford. Through examination of these records it is hoped/anticipated that patterns of adverse events like falls, sleep problems or worsening of depression symptoms can be detected.
Only summary numerical data will be extracted from participant’s medical records (for example, the number of times the participant had outpatient appointments with their team; a list of current medication and doses; any descriptions of side-effects of treatment). Data that describes a person or is unique to them (e.g. their date of birth or NHS number) will not be extracted or disclosed to the sponsor (Janssen) and Akrivia Health will not be able to determine the identity of a patient or access the participant’s source medical notes. Similarly, any summary data that could – in combination – be used to identify the participant will not be provided to the sponsor; for example, very specific symptoms, the participants address or occupation.
The study’s sponsor (Janssen) will benefit by having data from the external control arm that describes how patients progress in terms of side-effects, adverse events and healthcare contact when they continue their normal NHS standard of care for the treatment of depression. The results of this study will enable researchers at OHFT and the University of Oxford to establish if external control arms are feasible, practical and add important information to traditional clinical trials that could bring about benefit for patients in the future.
We are sorry you did not find this page helpful
Tell us how we can improve this page
Page last reviewed: 30 January, 2023